James
Basically, if you want a liberal arts school this is a really great one. Open curriculum is great, there are nice facilities and lots of good events. Most of the Sports teams are really good. The town is small, but close to bigger towns and there is free bus service with your student ID. If you want to be an engineer or a frat boy, go elsewhere, but otherwise this school is worth looking into.
Quick note: Any conservative students should know that it will be a challenge, but it can also really help you strengthen your arguments for the real world (plus, this place needs you). And for liberals looking to hear the conservative side, its there if you just look for it.
Tristan
If you come here, Amherst will take care of everything. Standard of living is pretty high (especially if you are an upperclassman and get in the top of room draw), some of the dorms are like hotels, classrooms are also modern and have multimedia technology; the campus has wireless, internet is fast; the campus is safe, we even have safe rides (campus police can give you a ride late at night to your dorm); the school gives out loans for personal laptops and for senior expenses (like interview- or grad-school-related expenses), financial aid in general is amazing; the food could be better, sometimes it is bland, but many times they have good stuff; and most importantly, all doors in life will be open for you after Amherst. You just don't need to worry, the college takes care of it all!
My social experience has been amazing and unforgettable. I have met so many interesting, thinking and unique people that I doubt I will ever meet in one place again. People are definitely smart, both academically and socially, the topics that are discussed are very intellectual and prepare you to what you will experience in a work environment. Almost everyone is passionate about an interest of theirs and you can learn soooo much only from one person, and you have tons of amazing people here. Although my social experience here is a blast, I have heard complaints from a few Americans about the cliques. Many Americans, though, share my excitement about the great students body. The international community is fantastic, so many mature, smart and talented people in one place! There is no gossip, intrigue or jealousy, everyone is friends with everyone. I still cannot get enough of those people! The international community is very diverse, there is no conceivable way that you would not find friends; even if they admitted a martian tomorrow, they will not feel lonely. It is also amazing that no one here is negative, people feel good about themselves and their future. They just do not worry about stuff. If you imply that you doubt you can do something, they will immediately cut you off and tell you that you are very smart and should not underestimate yourself. The place is very, very positive, it has some energy to it.
The weather, though, is cold. I love Amherst, but I have to admit, the winters are looooong. Pretty much your entire life at Amherst will be in cold weather. This should not prevent anyone from coming, in my opinion, but I just thought that this might matter to some people.
Disclaimer: this place is an academic machine! You are primarily a student, and everything else is secondary (may be this does not hold for athletes). It is almost impossible to find an easy class. Each of your classes could consume your entire life if you decided to follow the syllabus religiously. Come equipped with good work ethics and time-management skills, or you will be chronically sleep-deprived. In one of my semesters, I missed one week of school due to an illness and I had to pull all-nighters until the end of the semester. If you want 3.9, start working from day one.
Bottom line: many opportunities, fantastic people, tons of problems sets and reading (but interesting), engaging classes, the sweetest professors ever, modern dorms, cold weather, all-nighters, great financial aid, security, dynamic life, positive people: you will never wanna leave it!
Red
Basically, a lot of people at Amherst end up here because they were rejected from Harvard, Princeton, or Yale, though many people do infact decide to matriculate here after gaining admittance to a top Ivy. But everyone here, is happy that they ended up here. No one ever regrets choosing Amherst.